• Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • HOME
  • NEWS
  • DANCE
  • MUSIC & OPERA
  • PHOTOGRAPHY
  • Q&A DANCERS
  • Q&A SINGERS
  • GRAMILANO.PHOTOS
    • Dance
    • Italians
    • Italy
  • CONTACT

Gramilano

- dance, opera, photography...

Home › music & opera › Roberto Alagna tells his version of the Bastille walk out to Le Figaro

Roberto Alagna tells his version of the Bastille walk out to Le Figaro

18 September 2011 by gramilano 2 Comments

Share
Tweet
Pin
Share

After being accused provoking the departure of conductor Alain Lombard from the production of Faust at the Bastille, Roberto Alagna gave his version of what happened in an interview with Le Figaro.

I am very sad. I don’t understand the reaction of the press and the blogs which carry on without knowing the facts… precisely nothing happened!

I don’t disrespected Alain Lombard. He is a man with whom I have a friendship, and I respect his artistic opinions. He even said that after Franco Corelli he had never worked with such a kind singer.

We had one artistic disagreement about the Walpurgis scene where there’s a cut which he prefers, but I wanted to sing.

I was also late to a rehearsal once because of a road accident. The Maestro insisted on morning rehearsals, and as I live in the suburbs I had to travel for an hour and a half during the rush hour, so had to get up at 7am. A second delay was only seven minutes, which would have gone unnoticed if the rehearsal had begun with Siebel’s aria as scheduled. Lombard, believing that I was not going to arrive, sent everyone on a break. This is how a silly set of circumstances builds to create an absurd situation and fuel the gossip!

There appears to be a gap between Lombard’s conception of Faust and the implementation of his ideas. He is not angry with anyone but himself. During the orchestra rehearsals, he kept changing tempo, as if unable to find what he wanted. That is very disturbing for a singer, because everything is a matter of breathing. He said, “I can’t help it.” And when I pointed out to him that he wasn’t letting me breathe, he yelled, “I am not a soothsayer!” I was completely blocked. I’ve been singing Faust for twenty-eight years, I’m not a débutante, yet  it put me in difficulty. I therefore decided to withdraw from the production; the theatre convinced me to change my mind.

I had nothing do do in choosing his replacement, Alain Altinoglu, but the return to normalcy has lifted a great weight from the whole team.

The production opens on September 22.

Related

Filed Under: music & opera Tagged With: Faust, Roberto Alagna

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. antfreire says

    27 September 2011 at 16:22

    Every time there is a conflict between conductor and singer the press chooses to side up with the conductors. However history has proved that conductors many times are more primadonnas than singers. And let’s not forget that the singer is the one that has to face the audience. Conductors keep forgetting that people don’t go to see operas like Traviata, Lohengrin, Faust, that have been performed hundred if thouzands of times all around the world just to see Sir So and So conducting. People want to see the new tenor or the new soprano, and that’s the way it is.

    Reply
    • gramilano says

      27 September 2011 at 16:31

      Thanks for the comment. In fact Alagna complained about the tempi, and the impossibility to breathe; so important and yet many conductors ignore that to maintain the pace they’ve decided on. Certainly conductors who love singers (and often sing along as they’re conducting) rarely have operatic showdowns.

      Reply

Post a comment... Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

Follow us

  • 16,867 Fans
  • 277k Followers
  • 17,321 Subscribers
  • 28,134 Followers
  • 2,085 Followers
  • 592 Subscribers
  • 877 Subscribers

SEARCH

Sign up to our newsletter

Gramilano news 2019

Categories

Referred-to-by

News

  • English National Ballet’s Emerging Dancer finalists 2019
  • Karen Kain’s 50th Anniversary at National Ballet of Canada
  • 8 Prix de Lausanne 2019 Prize Winners announced - Finale Photo Album
  • Prix de Lausanne 2019 - Finalists
  • Viviana Durante, Meow Meow and Laura Morera recreate MacMillan’s Seven Deadly Sins
  • Matthew Bourne’s Swan Lake to be screened in cinemas 21 May
  • Jiří Bubeníček’s Carmen to debut at Rome Opera Ballet with Amar Ramasar as guest
  • Dancing Times, February edition - including Gramilano's Danza in Italia column with La Scala's new Nutcracker
  • Roberto Fascilla, former étoile at La Scala, dies at 82
  • Birmingham Royal Ballet announces its 2019/20 Season

Popular Music & Opera Posts

  • CD review: Diana Damrau in Meyerbeer's Grand Operas - a diva in her prime
  • La Scala remembers Dmitri Hvorostovsky who has died at 55
  • Interview with tenor Lawrence Brownlee on being a black man in America: Cycles of My Being
  • Renata Scotto vs Maria Callas - the 1970 fight at La Scala
  • Young mezzo Lilly Jørstad wins important grant from her 'homeland'
  • Vittorio Grigolo's new women's shoes and a song for Hillary Clinton
  • Interview with Anna Netrebko on her son, his autism and his abandonment by his father Erwin Schrott
  • Barbra Streisand's last concert
  • Stunning photos from La Scala archives celebrate Raina Kabaivanska’s return to the theatre
  • Daniela Dessi dies after a short illness, at 59

Graham Spicer

Writer, director and photographer in Milan, blogging (under the name 'Gramilano') about dance, opera, music and photography for people who are a bit like me and like some of the things I like.

I was a regular columnist for Opera Now magazine and wrote for the BBC until transferring to Italy. My scribblings have appeared in various publications from Woman's Weekly to Gay Times. I write the 'Danza in Italia' column for Dancing Times.

You can find me on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and Google+, or follow my Facebook page.



Copyright © 2019 · Gramilano · All rights reserved

about me · contact me · privacy and cookies